Sunday, September 4, 2011

2.1 Background information reviews           
As the preparation for the field visit, a background information review meeting was held at the GWRDP, Branch Office, and Nepalganj. The meeting was attended by GBO chief, hydrogeologist, engineer and other junior technical staffs. During the meeting detailed discussion and review of feasibility report, layout, drawings and cost estimate of the project was done. The team reviewed relavalent documents which include Governments policies, plan, legislation, regulation, guidelines, directives, international conventions and operation policies of World Bank. The review of document was focused on social, environment and technical aspect of SEMP.
2.2 Field Visit
The main purpose of field visit was to give information regarding implementation procedure of IWRMP and its component, to discuss the potential issues on social and environment impacts and to organize a walkthrough for the verification of issues raised in the mass meeting and desk study. WUA and other stakeholders were informed of the schedule and purpose of visit in advance. During field visit, a mass meeting was held at Tribeni Nagar, Samsergunj, Banke on 2065/7/6.
Mass Meeting: The mass meeting was attended by beneficiary’s farmers, WUA executive members; farmers’ group including local political leaders, VDC officials etc. During the meting the working procedures of the IWRMP was discussed. Beside these probable social and environmental impacts due to implementation of this project was also discussed. Farmers' view and suggestion were noted.
Walkthrough: Walk through along the proposed command area of the project was carried out with farmer beneficiaries and stake holders. Additional information about project features and environmental and social issues were noted down. Important project features were marked on topographical map.
Focus Group Discussion: Focus group discussion with women and Dalit/Schedule caste were made separately in the field. The ideas/issues expressed by them during the discussions were noted down. The discussion was held to assists these vulnerable groups to share the project benefits at par with others.
Social Mapping:  In order to make the beneficiary’s aware about the social and environmental issue, they ware encourage drawing social map. The study team assists the farmer to draw it. The map includes important project component.
Time Line Analysis:  Discussion with the local farmers to find out chronicles (Time Line Analysis) of major events of natural and human induced within the area which may have deep seeded impacts on the project area and its people.
2.3 Wrap-up Discussion and Debriefing.
Interactive discussions between farmers, other stake holders and team members were held to identify potential environmental and social issues. Issues as perceived by locals and pointed out by local knowledgeable persons were discussed and noted. Suggestions, comments and solutions presented by farmers/water users' were also noted down. Wrap-up discussion with farmers, other stake holders and team members was held at the end of day and suggested mitigation measures were debriefed and noted down. A meeting of line agencies viz. District Development Office, Nepal Electricity Authority, District Agriculture Office, Divisional Irrigational Office, District Women Development Office was also held at the Branch Office, Nepalganj.
Discussions among team members were again held at GWRDP, branch office, Nepalganj to make refinement on the findings made at the field level. Depending on the secondary data review, field observation, mass meeting, walkthrough, discussions etc., mitigation measures were suggested to minimize potential impacts.
2.4 Identification of Impacts and Mitigation Measures
This section deals with environmental and social issues, their magnitude, mitigation measures and responsible agency which were identified and observed by the team during field visit.
2.4.1 Acquisition of private land and property
The construction of tube well requires land for pump house, water distribution system. The land owner where these constructions of irrigation infrastructure are to be made agreed to give their part of land permanently (without compensation) according to the irrigation policy. Since there was no demand from the land owner the study team decided not conduct separate focus group discussion with them. It can be concluded, the magnitude of this impact is very low and the problem is easily manageable.
2.4.2 Water Management
The proposed deep tubewell projects have command area of about 400 ha of cultivable land. It is very easier said than done to supply the irrigation water in every part of the proposed land by buried uPVC pipe line and Alfa Alfa Valves. This may results in conflict between the beneficiary farmers. This problem will be solved by adopting following mitigation measure
Ø    Additional field channel should be made by WUG in the recommendation of GBO.
Ø    The appropriate location of Alfa Alfa valves and alignment of uPVC pipe should be decided by the combined team of WUA and GBO.
2.4.3 Operation and maintenance
Ground water irrigation requires energy for lifting water from electricity. Also the spare parts and electrical equipment required for operation and maintenance may be costly. The operation cost needs to be paid by the farmers, which is quite substantial for rural population. The magnitude of this impact would be medium, for long term and at sub-project level. For mitigation of this impact GBO/DADO/NGOs should conduct training about pump operation and maintenance, institutional strengthen and income generation for WUA.
2.4.4 Drawdown and interference effect
The hydro-geological investigation from previously drilled wells in the vicinity of the project area has shown that the area lies under the category of Northern Alluvium in adjacent to Bhabar zone. The groundwater potential in the Northern Alluvium is comparatively high due to direct infiltration from surface rivers and rainfall.
Over drafting of water from the tubewell may result water level decline and that might cause reasonable drawdown in the well. Simultaneous pumping of multiple tube wells in the cluster area may cause interference effect among each other, thus reducing the discharge and depletion of water table beneath desired pumping water level. The proposed deep tubewell irrigation system consists of 11 deep tubewell irrigation systems. For minimizing interference effect the spacing of tube wells has been kept distance of about 1km. The general rule is that, the spacing of 1 km of deep tubewell in the Terai is enough for preventing well interference. In addition the withdrawal of groundwater from these deep tubewells won’t be as such to affect the water table.  The magnitude of this impact would be low in the area for long term and at sub-project level since the withdrawal of groundwater is not very large.
2.4.5 Arsenic contamination
Arsenic contamination in groundwater is the potential issue in the Indo-gangetic basin. Arsenic survey has been extensively carried out in this region by Water supply & Sanitation Division Office, Nepalganj, Banke. The survey was carried out for shallow tubewells and hand pumps which extract water from shallow water bearing strata. The survey showed that the level of arsenic is within the permissible limit. For the deep seated aquifer, arsenic test can be carried out only after the completion of the Deep Tubewells. So that arsenic test needs to be carried out in post construction phase.
2.4.6 Water rights and equity issues
Given the fact that there is no groundwater irrigation system installed so far within the command area, naturally there are no issues of water rights and water use conflicts. If such case occurs, WUA will decide and manage all the beneficiaries despite their social background.
2.4.7 Conflict for sharing the benefit
In the discussion, it was indicated that there might be conflict in sharing the irrigation facility. The conflict aroused might lead to inequitable water distribution and thereby affecting the sustainability of irrigation system. Beneficiary farmers and the team agreed on following mitigation measures:
a)                  After the formation of WUA, development and implementation of rules regarding water sharing will be carried out.
b)                  There will be provisions of punishment for defaulters.
c)                  Farmers expressed their commitment to follow the rules and regulations regarding benefit sharing.
2.4.8 Sustainability of irrigation system
After completion of construction, tube well is tested for design discharge. Ensuring the flow of water through tube well in full fledges, responsibility is transferred to WUA for operation and minor maintenance. The sustainability of irrigation system is very crucial issue. There are significant numbers of groundwater projects which are failed in some parts of the districts and major causes are lack of proper pump operation and maintenance of the system and collection of electricity charge used by the consumers. Farmers have agreed to do following activities as mitigation measures:
a)                  Membership distribution to each consumer member.
b)                  Irrigation service fee (ISF) collection as per the hour basis.
c)                  Request GWRDP, Branch Office to train some local manpower for operation and minor maintenance of the submersible pump.
2.4.9 Issues of project affected people (PAP)
Location of DTWs to be drilled and of the pump house to be constructed has been fixed from discussion and walk through along with farmers. The command area to be irrigated has been delineated. The mass meeting agreed on the issues about project affected people. Project affected people are ready to contribute their land for DTW drilling, construction of pump house and water distribution system without any compensation.
2.4.10 Agro inputs and fertilizers
Mass meeting revealed that farmers locally produce low quality seeds which don’t give crop yield as per expectation. That's why following mitigation measures are recommended:
a)                  Request DADO for conducting training to produce good quality seeds.
b)                  Supply of improved seeds will be managed by co-operatives and farmer groups.
2.4.11 Gender issues
People in the sub-project area are not adversely affected from the gender discrimination. However, in focus group discussion, local women engaged in farming are interested to learn about modern agriculture practice and on-farm water management. For this, following activities will be carried out:
a)                  Training on preparation of organic manure, on-farm water management and modern agricultural practice will be provided by DADO and GBO.
b)                  Field and exposure visit will be arranged by DADO, NGO and GBO will support them to gain access to the development program of the concerned line agencies and other organization.
2.4.12 Employment opportunity to dalits and economically backward people
There are many dalits (lower caste population) in the project area. Most of them are migrant labors who work in India as construction and domestic labor for their livelihood. Traditionally they are treated as untouchable and local people do not feel comfortable to deal with them. In the past the upper cast people resist the involvement of lower cast in any development as well as social activities. In recent time there have been significant attitudinal changes in the society especially in young generation against this social discrimination. During focus group discussion, they were very enthusiastic to work as construction labor if given opportunity.
In this regard, it was agreed that dalit and economically backward members of society will be given high priority while hiring labor by contractor/WUA.
2.5. SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN
The table no 1 shows the summary matrix of all the above discussed issue along with affected entity, mitigation measures and responsible agency to solve.

2.6. MONITORING MECHANISM AND PLAN
Social and environmental impacts identification and application of mitigation measures will be routinely monitored during pre-construction, construction and post-construction phase by responsible agencies and stakeholders in sub-project levels, WUA/GBO followed by Project Director Office, Office of the District Development Committee, Chief District Officer and other district level line agencies (Nepal Electricity Authority/District Agriculture Development Office.

0 comments:

Popular Posts

Text Widget